Scientific Proof that Cooper's Dunk was the GOAT

Has anyone found a way to hear David Shumate’s call of the dunk? I saw it mentioned in an article but it didn’t provide audio. Would love to hear the excitement from him.
 
Has anyone found a way to hear David Shumate’s call of the dunk? I saw it mentioned in an article but it didn’t provide audio. Would love to hear the excitement from him.
Never mind, it’s in that compilation video that someone posted on page one. Great stuff!
 
Has anyone found a way to hear David Shumate’s call of the dunk? I saw it mentioned in an article but it didn’t provide audio. Would love to hear the excitement from him.
I heard the radio call SEVERAL times driving home from Cameron on the postgame show which was awesome. Then, later on SportsCenter after the golf on ESPN they showed the dunk and then showed it with Shumate's call. Fun night!
 
Somehow, we've made it to the second page of this thread (which has evolved to also serve as an impromptu "best Duke dunks thread") and no mention of my favorite Duke dunk. Shameful.

But still not as much shame as Nick VanderLaan must have felt.

This was the first one I thought of in terms of poster dunks.

That said, and I've looked at the impressive ones in this thread, Cooper's dunk has a strong case for the best one I've seen by a Blue Devil. Especially considering the ferocity over a 7 foot defender. Watching it in real time, I didn't even think he would attempt, let alone complete that dunk.
 
This was the first one I thought of in terms of poster dunks.

That said, and I've looked at the impressive ones in this thread, Cooper's dunk has a strong case for the best one I've seen by a Blue Devil. Especially considering the ferocity over a 7 foot defender. Watching it in real time, I didn't even think he would attempt, let alone complete that dunk.
Diaz Graham may be 7 foot, but he is no Ralph Sampson or Alonzo Mourning.
 
Diaz Graham may be 7 foot, but he is no Ralph Sampson or Alonzo Mourning.

Evaluating dunks is obviously based on aesthetics and therefore subjective. For me, the defending player's reputation doesn't matter as much as the defense played in that specific play.

That said, the fact that I didn't see the older dunks live in the flow of the game may impact my perception.
 
Evaluating dunks is obviously based on aesthetics and therefore subjective. For me, the defending player's reputation doesn't matter as much as the defense dwidtnjh in that specific play.

That said, the fact that I didn't see the older dunks live in the flow of the game may impact my perception.
I saw them all and each is uniquely great and not subject to any objective ranking. To try to do so is a fools errand and a waste of bandwidth.
 
I agree ranking dunks is subjective. But though Flagg's dunk was spectacular (I'm bowing, accolades given, total respect), IMO it wasn't my greatest dunk in Duke history. Likely top 10, maybe even top 5, but not #1. I'm actually not sure what would be my #1, as I think each dunk has its own context. Athletically, the Zion dunk v. UVA was the most powerful and most impressive. He was like a tank doing ballet down the court, then windmilling it in over Huff. My gawd... GHill v. Kansas was the most meaningful being it was the early moment's of the '91 national championship, which Duke had not won yet at that time. Kansas and Ol' Roy looked at that in awe (along with the rest of us) and basically lost the game there... Henderson against Mourning and GTown in the '89 E8 was the most arrogant - "We aren't afraid of you, and we are going to win this game" dunk. Remember GTown was the #1 seed and Alonzo was a beast of a shot blocker... Dawkins doing the '86 reverse dunk, "kiss my @ss as we rout you Navy and go to the FF", was perhaps the most celebratory, closely followed by GHill (again) doing the reverse slam as the coda in that 2nd half run against Michigan in the '92 Final (time to go to bed, Fab Five kids - he should have started Curry's night-night thing then). And he was here for too short a time, but Cassius Stanley's dunk v. Miami where he flew through the lane and caught the inbound pass/alley oop one-handed and jammed it was an amazing airborne spectacle (this video below says it was #6, which IMO was way off). In fact, I think Stanley might have had the greatest dunking single season at Duke of all time (him being "only" 6'5" helps the visuals).


9F
 
I agree ranking dunks is subjective. But though Flagg's dunk was spectacular (I'm bowing, accolades given, total respect), IMO it wasn't my greatest dunk in Duke history. Likely top 10, maybe even top 5, but not #1. I'm actually not sure what would be my #1, as I think each dunk has its own context. Athletically, the Zion dunk v. UVA was the most powerful and most impressive. He was like a tank doing ballet down the court, then windmilling it in over Huff. My gawd... GHill v. Kansas was the most meaningful being it was the early moment's of the '91 national championship, which Duke had not won yet at that time. Kansas and Ol' Roy looked at that in awe (along with the rest of us) and basically lost the game there... Henderson against Mourning and GTown in the '89 E8 was the most arrogant - "We aren't afraid of you, and we are going to win this game" dunk. Remember GTown was the #1 seed and Alonzo was a beast of a shot blocker... Dawkins doing the '86 reverse dunk, "kiss my @ss as we rout you Navy and go to the FF", was perhaps the most celebratory, closely followed by GHill (again) doing the reverse slam as the coda in that 2nd half run against Michigan in the '92 Final (time to go to bed, Fab Five kids - he should have started Curry's night-night thing then). And he was here for too short a time, but Cassius Stanley's dunk v. Miami where he flew through the lane and caught the inbound pass/alley oop one-handed and jammed it was an amazing airborne spectacle (this video below says it was #6, which IMO was way off). In fact, I think Stanley might have had the greatest dunking single season at Duke of all time (him being "only" 6'5" helps the visuals).


9F
From now on I will pronounce his name Cassius STANley.
 
I agree ranking dunks is subjective. But though Flagg's dunk was spectacular (I'm bowing, accolades given, total respect), IMO it wasn't my greatest dunk in Duke history. Likely top 10, maybe even top 5, but not #1. I'm actually not sure what would be my #1, as I think each dunk has its own context. Athletically, the Zion dunk v. UVA was the most powerful and most impressive. He was like a tank doing ballet down the court, then windmilling it in over Huff. My gawd... GHill v. Kansas was the most meaningful being it was the early moment's of the '91 national championship, which Duke had not won yet at that time. Kansas and Ol' Roy looked at that in awe (along with the rest of us) and basically lost the game there... Henderson against Mourning and GTown in the '89 E8 was the most arrogant - "We aren't afraid of you, and we are going to win this game" dunk. Remember GTown was the #1 seed and Alonzo was a beast of a shot blocker... Dawkins doing the '86 reverse dunk, "kiss my @ss as we rout you Navy and go to the FF", was perhaps the most celebratory, closely followed by GHill (again) doing the reverse slam as the coda in that 2nd half run against Michigan in the '92 Final (time to go to bed, Fab Five kids - he should have started Curry's night-night thing then). And he was here for too short a time, but Cassius Stanley's dunk v. Miami where he flew through the lane and caught the inbound pass/alley oop one-handed and jammed it was an amazing airborne spectacle (this video below says it was #6, which IMO was way off). In fact, I think Stanley might have had the greatest dunking single season at Duke of all time (him being "only" 6'5" helps the visuals).


9F
That looks like SO much fun.
 
On many of the videos above it tells me I have to sign in to confirm I’m not a bot to view them. Sign in to what???
 
Back
Top