I agree with this. When I use (or think of) the term "handed the keys," I think of Duke freshmen PGs who were recruited to, and unequivocally did, run the team from day-1. I don't offer that term lightly. Of Kedsy's list, the only players I would offer that term to are:
Greg Paulus (who held the keys from 2005 until at least 2008, when they were turned over to maybe Demarcus Nelson (non-freshman) and then phased into Jon Scheyer (non-freshman) )
Kyrie Irving, no question
Austin Rivers, kind of, although he clearly was not an optimal, prototypical PG
[lull as we turned to transfer Seth Curry and non-freshman Quinn Cook]
Tyus Jones, no question
[I would not include Derryck Thornton, who reclassed to help us out, but was simply too young/green to adequately run the team; and I think we knew that when we took him in, so would not say we "handed him the keys"]
[nor would I include Frank Jackson who ascended into a role as the season progressed]
Trevon Duval, who was uber athletic but not, what I would call, a prototypical PG
Tre Jones, barely but I'll give it to him
Jeremy Roach, is a tough call, he was indeed the nominal PG but did we really "give him the keys?" I guess we kinda did, but that was
So Paulus, Irving, Rivers, Jones, Duval, Jones, and maybe Roach.
Jay Will and Duhon were before my time, at least following recruiting and what we were truly intending with them ahead of their arrival.
- Chillin