Ymm, Pies

[LasVegas]

You are a genius.

It’s also very similar to Key Lime Pie. So one can’t be a pie and the other a cake.

[ClemmonsDevil]

It’s also very similar to Key Lime Pie. So one can’t be a pie and the other a cake.

Impossibly well reasoned argument. So obviously we all agree. These are the facts of the case, and they are undisputed. Cheesecake is pie. So my answer is Cheesecake with cherries on top.

[dudog84]

Cherry Pie.

What other pie has a Top 10 song named after it?

'nuff said.

[OldPhiKap]

Cherry Pie.

What other pie has a Top 10 song named after it?

'nuff said.

American Pie.



And a band: Humble Pie (no US top 10 singles though. Two top 10 US albums, and one UK top 10 single)

[Mtn.Devil.91.92.01.10.15]

Chicken pot.

[Tripping William]

Shepherd’s

[aimo]

Chicken pot.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ApmvDU5RmyY

[dudog84]

American Pie.



And a band: Humble Pie (no US top 10 singles though. Two top 10 US albums, and one UK top 10 single)

I need your recipes for these please.

[Phredd3]

Now if we want to agree that Cheesecake exists in a delicious and previously undefined nether realm between cake and pie, I can agree. It ain't cake.

This one. It is neither pie nor cake. It is its own, wonderful thing. The consistency is neither cake-like nor pie-like. It's not even custard-filled pie, and both appearance and texture will tell you so unequivocally. Cheesecake belongs in its own, delicious world to be appreciated on its own merits.

[freshmanjs]

Do we all agree that Boston Cream Pie is a cake?

[ClemmonsDevil]

This one. It is neither pie nor cake. It is its own, wonderful thing. The consistency is neither cake-like nor pie-like. It's not even custard-filled pie, and both appearance and texture will tell you so unequivocally. Cheesecake belongs in its own, delicious world to be appreciated on its own merits.

Too late. Las Vegas decided.

[Phredd3]

Too late. Las Vegas decided.

Everyone knows that Las Vegas doesn't decide anything. It just takes its cut. And after all, if there are three categories, that's an extra cut for the house.

[ClemmonsDevil]

Everyone knows that Las Vegas doesn't decide anything. It just takes its cut. And after all, if there are three categories, that's an extra cut for the house.

Are you suggesting I made a controversial statement, waited for some unsuspecting poster to agree, and then blamed that poster as the person who made the assertion originally? Wow. You think you know someone.

[LasVegas]

Everyone knows that Las Vegas doesn't decide anything. It just takes its cut. And after all, if there are three categories, that's an extra cut for the house.

I won’t allow it unless I get some resort fees.

[Phredd3]

I won’t allow it unless I get some resort fees.

Typical Vegas...

[OldPhiKap]

Pizza pie.

[Tripping William]

80CDBDC5-5322-466C-81B3-CCA9B2480F2E.jpg

[rsvman]

I am with Phredd3 on all counts.
First, that cheesecake is neither a cake nor really a pie. It is its own thang.
And second, that the best pie is banana cream pie.

[Jim3k]

Cherry, then rhubarb. Or rhubarb, and then cherry.

[rsvman]

Custard pie has got to be near the top.

Oh, sorry, I thought this was the thread about worst opening songs on epic Led Zeppelin albums. My bad.