I hadn't heard about The Illusionist, but may have to give it a chance. Aside from Ed Norton, I'm skeptical about it having better acting than the Prestige. I'm not much of a Giamatti fan (but like him ok), don't care for Sewell, and can't stand Biel.
I've been interested in the Matador for a long time, but haven't broken down and paid full price for it yet (I can never seem to find it on sale).
I haven't yet seen the Queen or Children of Men. As good as The Queen is supposed to be, any plotline involving Princess Diana just puts me off. It just doesn't interest me. Children of Men struck me as a Clive Owen action flick, and I'm not a big Clive Owen fan... however, the reviews seem to indicate otherwise, so perhaps I should give it a go.