Originally Posted by
johnb
Not to pick on one bit of this particular post. I do the same thing when I assert that Zion needs to play at a weight 20 pounds less than his lowest playing weight since 10th grade. Or when I assert (from the comfort of my couch) that Trevor (and a couple of recent Duke guys who haven’t thrived in the NBA) desperately need to lower their body fat—I’m basically asserting that it just takes more effort. I wonder how accurate any of us are are when we shift from observable information to assertions about mindset, effort, and training.
Your particular assertion may be true, for example, but how do we know about Cam’s effort/commitment, or anyone’s? Some guys have a reputation for being gym rats (because they stay late, according to their coaches or PR firm), and some guys have especially low body fats and fast sprints or high jumps. But there is a limit on how much an individual can improve.
Plenty of extremely hard working gym rats peak as 6th men on their mediocre high school team, and other guys—like Ben Simmons or our own Billy King—have/had superlative skills without commensurate ability to hit a 20 foot jumper. And it’s not like they didn’t think they might want to practice that outside shot. Similarly, great defense among mediocre 13 year olds is largely about effort, I’d guess, but at the elite level, there’s something about fast twitch muscle fibers, arm length, teammates, coaching, and an intrinsic understanding of court dynamics (here should go a photo of Shane Battier, who was unusually prescient but also a 6’8” great athlete, so it wasn’t all brains).
Anyway, I’m reminded that there are things I do easily and well, and other things that just don’t come to me naturally. And there are some things that I did very well, like math, but when I rubbed elbows with real mathematicians, I realized I should look for a different career.
How can Cam become an RJ with a better jump shot? I have no idea, but since there’d be $200m in CamDollars riding on the transition, I’m guessing someone has mulled it over. He does look relaxed on the court, but almost all of our players aside from Hurley and Wojo have tended to look serious but relaxed on the court. But I’m guessing that doesn’t mean they’re taking it casually. Anyway, this is mostly a personal mull, but when I (or anyone) starts to make specific suggestions, well, unless we’re very knowledgeable about someone’s actual training habits AND about how to develop an elite basketball player, I’m skeptical that our suggestions are useful.