I thought perhaps you didn't care for older fare because of the Breen/Hayes Code or something. But to be honest, I think 1935-1955 is my favorite film era. Not sure it's because of the Code though. I certainly like modern films as well. Perhaps it's just that I'm a sucker for old westerns and comedies. Or maybe I just enjoy watching Dorothy Lamour in a sarong*. Not sure.
*I realize that reference will miss almost everyone here, but it's the truth.