Originally Posted by
ClemmonsDevil
I would say by arm talent and ability to make pretty much any throw he's the most talented quarterback I have ever seen. I hate the zero-sum game of counting championships as the only measure of this, but it is certainly a measure. And he won a Super Bowl. He's definitely not a choker, but I'm also someone who doesn't really believe in that term. Or at least believes it's misapplied. I think he is unquestionably one of the all-time greats. He and Marino are top 10 easily. Just unbelievable quarterbacks. If my life depended on it and I needed one dude to make the most difficult throw in NFL history he's one of the two or three guys on the list with Peyton Manning and Marino. But if I need to win the biggest game of my life then I am going with Brady or Joe Montana.