QBs taken in the first 10 picks over the last 25 drafts (1995-2019), ranked by CarAV (weighted career approximate value), per
www.sports-reference.com
Player – Year – Draft Position – CarAV
PManning 1998-1 177
Rivers 2004-4 140
Ryan 2008-3 129
EManning 2004-1 117
Palmer 2003-1 108
McNabb 1999-2 107
Newton 2011-1 103
McNair 1995-3 100
-----------------------------
Smith 2005-1 96
Vick 2001-1 93
Stafford 2009-1 91
-----------------------------
Collins 1995-5 81
-----------------------------
Luck 2012-1 71
-----------------------------
Tannehill 2012-8 54
-----------------------------
Bradford 2010-1 44
Bortles 2014-3 44
Carr 2002-1 44
Winston 2015-1 41
Mariota 2015-2 40
-----------------------------
Griffin III 2012-2 35
Sanchez 2009-5 34
Young 2006-3 33
Leftwich 2003-7 33
Wentz 2016-2 32
Goff 2016-1 30
Harrington 2002-3 30
Couch 1999-1 30
-----------------------------
Mahomes 2017-10 23
Trubisky 2017-2 20
-----------------------------
Gabbart 2011-10 16
Locker 2011-8 15
Leinart 2006-10 12
Mayfield 2018-1 10
-----------------------------
Darnold 2018-3 7
Allen 2018-7 6
Russell 2007-1 6
Rosen 2018-10 2
Smith 1999-3 1
Leaf 1998-2 1
-----------------------------
Murray 2019-1 0
DJ 2019-6 0