Not sure I'm with you on this one, brev. There are plenty of reasons a new freshman might get on campus and get cold feet that we wouldn't have an issue with for a regular student (homesickness, not feeling comfortable in the campus atmosphere, mental health challenges, etc.), so without knowing more about the situation here I'm not sure we should rush to judgement. More specifically to basketball, if a coach can change his roster at the last minute through the portal, why can't a player change his mind at the last minute if the opportunities he was sold on during recruiting are no longer there? While in an ideal world recruits pick their school based on the school, culture, atmosphere, and opportunity, the reality is playing time is a huge factor as well. If that changes suddenly, I don't see why an incoming freshman shouldn't have the freedom that we now give established players in the transfer portal.
Now again, this is something where some regulation from the NCAA (which of course will never happen) would make things a lot nicer. There should be an "end period" for transfers, graduate or not, so that freshmen know the team they're joining in the summer. Easy solution: have the "transfer window" end two weeks before summer practices can officially start (beginning of July?), and then add in a two week period where freshman can request releases from their LOIs and "pre-transfer". Add in a mechanism by which prospective grad transfers have to declare their intention to grad transfer beforehand (in case they need a semester to fully graduate or something) that's universal and must be respected by both incoming and outgoing institutions (so that, for instance, the Terrance Shannon/Michigan situation of last year can't happen), and things get much smoother and more predictable. Again, though, this will never happen
