Virginia
Clemson
Duke
Louisville
North Carolina
Miami
Virginia Tech
Syracuse
North Carolina St
Florida St
Notre Dame
Boston College
Georgia Tech
Wake Forest
Pittsburgh
Polls generally are underused on DBR, imo. Here's one that might be interesting.
Use the poll, and then if you have commentary, post that in the thread. Is the conference going to have double-digit bids this season?
If you pick the ACC's contingent exactly, much praise will be heaped upon you in March.
If you miss even one team, you are a LOSER.
Virginia, Duke, Clemson, and UNC are locks.
Four others should be in: VT (winning record, beat the best team in the country on their floor), NC State (3 incredible wins), Lousiville (they'll get in. Too much talent + winning record), and Miami (great non-conference, winning record in the ACC).
Criticism may not be agreeable, but it is necessary. It fulfils the same function as pain in the human body. It calls attention to an unhealthy state of things. - Winston Churchill
President of the "Nolan Smith Should Have His Jersey in The Rafters" Club
I think 9 or 10 get in:
UVa, Duke, Clemson, UNC, Miami, and 4 of Va Tech, FSU, Louisville, Syracuse, and NC State. Notre Dame could get into the mix if Colson returns for the ACC tournament and Notre Dame makes a run.
Will wait until closer to the deadline before deciding as lots of the bubble teams still play each other.
"We are not provided with wisdom, we must discover it for ourselves, after a journey through the wilderness which no one else can take for us, an effort which no one can spare us, for our wisdom is the point of view from which we come at last to regard the world." --M. Proust
I'm leaving out Louisville.
They have ONE top 50 win...@ #44 FSU back in early Januarly.
Their best two chances for more wins are @VT and @State, both of which I like in some home cooking. The Duke game is in Cameron, so that's a W for Duke. UofL has shown me nothing to think they can beat UVa...that's leaves the Cheaters and the Cheats. I hate to predict any sort of success for Carolina, but since the Cardinals have a better academic reputation than the Tarheels I'll give the edge to the team that is willing to completely sell out their soul and reputation to win games.
If the Cards drop the next 5 games and a grand total of one win against the Top 50, I don't think the selection comittee will shown them any mercy. They'd rather have an NC State or VT who have shown they can beat Top 10 teams on more than one occassion. Granted, both State and VT have more work to do (State more than VT), but W's over UofL would go a long way toward punching their ticket.
Criticism may not be agreeable, but it is necessary. It fulfils the same function as pain in the human body. It calls attention to an unhealthy state of things. - Winston Churchill
President of the "Nolan Smith Should Have His Jersey in The Rafters" Club
I picked UVA, Duke, Clemson, Louisville, Miami, UNC, VT, FSU not in that order. I used RPI Forecast/Sagarin.
I don't think criteria will change much with the addition of Pomeroy et al. Barring exceptional circumstances, you still need 9-9 in the ACC, <14 losses, and have an RPI < 50. Some teams that I think will be out barring an ACC Tournament run:
Syracuse: Projected 8-10 and RPI in 40's. They lack quality wins to overcome 8-10.
ND: Project 8-10 and RPI in 60's. They might get First Four because of the injuries if they can win 2 in the ACC tournament.
NCSU: Projected 9-9 and RPI in 80's. Despite 4-5 against RPI Top 25, the numbers here are bad in RPI and Pomeroy.
I suck at these things. It is like filling out brackets.
I always pick Duke, and will never pick unc. NEVER.
If you end up winning this contest, let us know. (Did I mention I wasn't going to tally this stuff?)
Anyway, if Louisville is out of the tourney as is the expectation right now, then 41 out of 47 players will already be LOSERS. I wonder if anyone will have gotten 8 for 8 correct (again, assuming no surprises).
Virginia
Clemson
Duke
North Carolina
Miami
Virginia Tech
North Carolina St
Florida St
EDIT: Oops...didn’t realize this poll was so old.
Everyone was a LOSER.
The least loser-ish predictors (even though they are still LOSERs) were arguably tbyers11 and PackMan97.
tbyers got Louisville being out correct but couldn't quite predict that Syracuse would be in.
PackMan97 got both Louisville out and Syracuse in correct but omitted FSU from the tourney.
Better luck next year, forum.