As the resident BrewDevil Dark Lord Day corespondent, I took it upon myself to have a few beers last night (Crowler of Dragons Milk Stroopwafel and a 2019 regular Dark Lord for inspiration) and put together a rough ranking system for the potential DL variants we should be hoping to see in our totes in a couple of weeks... That being said, as my kids have heard as much as GTHC in our household; you get what you get and you don't throw a fit
Included are the overall scores (out of 5) from Untappd, along with any insider info I've come across in my DL travels.
The "Russian Roulette" Class
34. Turtledogg (2018)
2.87 - Aged in scotch barrels. As legend has it, a rookie Dark Lord Day attendee traded a top 3 beer in the world for this unfortunate entry in the DL collection. It now sits in his cellar and will be opened to celebrate title #6. Considered the "Kobe for Vlade Divac" or "Babe Ruth for No, No Nanette" of the beer trading universe.
33. ReptileFund (2019)
3.33 – Aged in bourbon barrels and finished in mescal barrels
32. Greatest Teachable Moments (2018)
3.37 - Aged in apple brandy barrels with verbena, ginger and orange peel
31. French Vanilla Militia (2017)
4.15 – Aged in Sauternes barrels with vanilla, cocoa nibs and coffee. A true hit or miss in the DL world; a large number of the '17 FVM were infected, so it's unclear at this point if the ones cellared at 3F may have suffered the same fate and will be drain pours.
The "Acquired Taste" Class
30. Brosure (2019)
4.15 – Aged in ruby red port barrels
29. Trump and Pump (2016)
4.19 – Aged in Sauternes wine barrels
28. Cavaliero of Varnov (2018)
4.24 – Aged in Oloroso sherry barrels
27. Legio Gemina (2016)
4.27 – Aged in Pineau de Charentes barrels
26. Brotilla (2018)
4.29 – Aged in Carcavelos wine barrles
25. Cavaliero of Varnov (2019)
4.30 – Aged in Calvados brandy barrels
24. Brozerker (2018)
4.32 – Aged in ruby port barrels
The "Solid If Unspectacular" Class
23. French Vanilla Militia (2018)
4.33
22. Conquistador De Muerte (2017)
4.33 – Aged in bourbon barrels with guajillo peppers
21. 2-year Portuguese Brandy BA (2015)
4.37
The "3F Heat Check" Class
As you'll see in the scores, the regular 2019 BBA and Rye DLs were more highly regarded, meaning 3F utilizing their new Divine Rite barrels was at a detriment to the tastebuds.
20. BA Bourbon x DVR (2019)
4.36 - Aged in bourbon barrels then finished in their Divine Rite malt whiskey barrels
19. BA Rye x DVR (2019)
4.39 – Aged in rye barrels then finished in their Divine Rite malt whiskey barrels
18. Aquavit BA (2015)
4.46 - Aged in Aquavit barrels, which 98% of people will need to Google
17. Brandy BA (2011)
4.51 - One of their first Brandy aged DLs, well received at the time. Unclear if the flavors will still be as delectable 9 years later.
The "Bread and Butter at a 5* Italian Restaurant" Class
16. Rye BA (2019)
4.44
15. Bourbon BA (2019)
4.45
14. Hung Drawn and Quartered (2018) 4.48 – Fancy name for the 2018 Rye BA
13. Bourbon BA (2012)
4.61
The "Untappd Rankings Are Wrong" Class
I've had both of these within the past 6 months, and both were better than the 2019 Handjee IMO
12. French Vanilla Militia (2019)
4.32
11. Lounge Against the Macromachine (2019)
4.38
The "Coinflip" Class
10. Bourbon BA (2013)
4.68 – 2 styles of BBA DL were released in 2013, one with vanilla beans (later known as the first Marshmallow Handjee) and one with guajillo peppers. If this is the Handjee it jumps up into the Top 5.
The "Experiments That Played Their Way Into Late Lottery Picks" Class
9. Loadstar (2019)
4.53 – Aged in Sauternas whiskey barrels with toasted coconuts
8. ‘Rrari Crochet (2019)
4.57 – Aged in port whiskey barrels with vanilla beans, strawberries, cocoa nibs and toasted coconuts
7. Lounge Against the Macromachine (2018)
4.61 – Aged in bourbon barrels then finished in tequila barrels with cinnamon, cocoa nibs, guajillo peppers and tangerine peels
The "Don't Hurt Yourself Celebrating Seeing This Bottle In Your Tote" Class
6. Chemtrailmix (2019)
4.64 - Aged in Rye barrels w/ cinnamon and pink peppercorns. Sounds iffy on paper, plays like a Stones brother.
5. Marshmallow Handjee (2019)
4.69
4. Chemtrailmix (2017)
4.70
3. Marshmallow Handjee (2017)
4.78 - Ranking was elevated by all the Beer Bros on the West Coast who couldn't get their hands on a 2018
2. Chemtrailmix (2018)
4.72
The "Zion" Class
1. Marshmallow Handjee (2018)
4.75
May the odds be ever in your favor!