Originally Posted by
calltheobvious
The period from 1973-1992 is a very important one in Auburn University history. Its endpoints are the first year in a nine-year losing streak to Bear Bryant's Alabama teams, and the ignominious retirement of Coach Pat Dye, who wilted under the pressure of NCAA investigations for paying players, investigations that would lead to two years of probation for the Tigers.
In 1981 Dye arrived at Auburn, and in 1982 he ended the streak against Alabama. He went on to win four SEC titles in the 80's, and was a stubborn conservative-streak away from winning a national championship in 1983 (Auburn was the only team in the top four to win on New Year's Day, but Dye played it extremely close to the vest in the Sugar Bowl leaving Auburn with an uninspiring 9-7 victory over Michigan and, and Miami with the leapfrog title). For many Auburn fans who came of age feeling like Alabama's whipping boy, Pat Dye is a saint, the inveterate cheating notwithstanding.
This is especially true for Auburn's two most prominent trustees. Robert Lowder is the chairman of Colonial Bank Group and an ardent Dye supporter; and Jimmy Raine is the chairman of Southern Wood, and has described Dye as "the father I never had." For these two men, the sun rises and sets with Patrick Fain Dye.
Enter Terry Bowden, who was hired in 1993 under the presumption that a guy from Samford couldn't really be successful long-term, but would serve as a willing puppet for a couple of years until probation was over and a real candidate could be hired. The fly in the ointment was that Bowden won his first 20 games at Auburn and became untouchable until the 1998 season when several years of lazy recruiting finally caught up with him and he was forced out.
It's not widely known that Bowden was almost out a year earlier. Lowder had a replacement ready to take Bowden's job after the 1997 Alabama game. Even after losing a battle of undefeateds against Florida that year, Auburn was highly ranked and looked like it would make it to Atlanta with a 10-1 record. But when heavy underdog Mississippi State came to Auburn and whipped the Tigers 20-0, the wheels were set in motion for a replacement. And with a minute left and Alabama up two with the football, it looked like Terry was cooked for sure. But an Alabama fumble and a 43-yard Auburn field goal later, Bowden had saved himself, and an entire coaching staff in Oxford, Mississippi let out a sigh of disappointment and unpacked their bags. Yep, that coaching staff.
More background. Part of Bowden's hiring was contingent upon retaining a sizeable chunk of Dye's staff. But when Bowden went 20-1-1 his first two years, he had the leverage he needed to start cleaning house, literally and figuratively. By 1996 he had gotten rid of Dye's fiercest and dirtiest henchman. Problem was, after Bowden lost a heart-breaker to Peyton Manning in the SECC game in 1997, a game Auburn led 20-7 in the first half, his political capital was gone, and when things started 1-5 in 1998, he was toast.
Things were a little different with Tuberville. He told Auburn he wasn't coming without his entire staff from Ole Miss, and after a 3-8 season and a bare cupboard, Lowder and the puppet president and AD were in no position to say no. So Tuberville came in, almost got Auburn to a bowl in '99 (no mean feat with a 5-8, 170-pound tailback), then surprised everyone by winning the division in 2000. In 2001 Auburn beat #1 Florida at home, and then upset #9 Alabama on the road at the end of 2002. Despite a drubbing by Alabama at the end of 2001, TT was 2-2 against an Alabama program that was by then in shambles, and Auburn was a pre-season top five in 2003. Things were looking good.
Then after five disappoing losses Jetgate happened, a PR nightmare ensued for Auburn, Tuberville held on to his job, and the president and AD were fired. New puppets were hired, but Auburn went undefeated in 2004, and Tuberville became ten times more untouchable than even Bowden was after 1994. Lowder was frustrated that he had no influence whatsoever on the football program. It was killing him. Tuberville was winning, graduating players who were staying out of trouble, no hint of NCAA violations; exactly what a rational person would want out of the coach of their favorite team. But Lowder can't be happy unless he's in control. So he just lay in wait, knowing that he had an ace in the hole with Jay Jacobs, the no-talent-zero yokel of an athletics director, and not coincidentally a former player for Pat Dye. So 2008 was it, the opportunity Lowder and Co. had been waiting for to force out the guy who wouldn't play ball.
If Alabama hadn't had a great year, maybe Tuberville hangs on, but with the Tide rolling again and Saban being Saban, the knives were out. None of TT's on-field or off-field success mattered. All that mattered was the deep pathology of Lowder, Raine, and Dye; specifically their deep inferiority complex regarding everything University-of-Alabama. They see Dye as Moses, and think they again need his stewardship in order to find their way out of their perceived desert.
An obvious problem is that most any coach worth his salt is not going to agree to have his staff managed by two jock-sniffers and a nincompoop. That's why Gary Patterson turned down Auburn down during his interview, and why Turner Gill was never a serious candidate.
But Gene Chizik? Ooh, now we got something. Here's a guy who's one year away from getting fired at Iowa State. If that had happened, he'd never have gotten another D1 offer as HC. He was in no position to say no to anything, and Dye knew it. He was Dye's choice from the beginning, which is to say he was Jacobs's, too. Gill and Rodney Garner were indeed token minority interviews. But Patterson, Hoke, et all were token majority interviews. There was no search. Chizik was the guy from the beginning, because he was the only guy willing to do the bidding of the Auburn power brokers.
Now Chizik is going to fill his staff with a lot of Dye retreads, which means the gloves are off. He's already hired the old recruiting coordinator. Auburn will be cheating again by dusk, Alabama probably already is, and they'll start paying PI's to get the goods on each other the same way they did in the 90s. That's when Alabama probation followed Auburn probation. It's going to get really, really nasty again, and the image of the entire state is going to suffer as a result. Heartbreaking, really.
So, everyone can ask, "What was Auburn thinking?" But without the relevant context no one can understand. The assumption would be that it was a rational decision. The important thing for everyone to know, though, is that the decision wasn't rational. It was completely pathological.
Auburn will win again, but they will not win with dignity, and I won't spend another dime in Jordan-Hare Stadium until the house has been cleaned. I can only hope enough others feel the same way for it to make a difference.