Sabathia's case for the Cy is strong, but I just don't see how Tim Lincecum's body of work over the season can be denied. !7-5 for a team that was under .400 when he wasn't pitching, 2.66 ERA, leading the majors in strikeouts by a bunch.
By way of patting myself on the back, and as a cautionary tale for those who doubt my prognosticative powers, I'll note that I posted here in March of last year after seeing Lincecum in spring training, before he'd thrown an inning in the majors, that he was an absolute freak. Of course really, all you need is a pair of functioning eyes to pick up on that. There were, however, a lot of doubters about his size.