Goodness - Tripping William always has great answers to best restaurants in Winston.
My favorite pizza in town (and one of my favorite restaurants) is River Birch Lodge! They always have multiple outstanding feature beers on tap (like Burial). They always have featured wood-fired grill pizzas with interesting and changing combo's of ingredients. Just so good.
I also love Mellow Mushroom downtown.
Jenn likes Cugino Forno and says it's popular but I've never had it. Elizabeth's and Mario's are quite popular. Burke Street Pizza is a Winston classic (but many of these are more New York style so not my thing).
I like Papa John's, Dominos, and Pizza Hut pan.
This sounds like a side-by-side will be needed to clarify rankings in the not too distant future :cool: