NBA collective bargaining agreement discussion
I decided to move my response to a new thread at the request of many posters. If you want to see the background to this see the John Wall recruitment thread on about pages 39-41.
I made the following comment after a lot of very good discussion:
"But the main problem I have is that the NBA's rule affects college basketball and the NCAA does not seem to want to do anything about it. "
Jim Sumner responded:
"At the risk of belaboring the obvious, the NCAA cannot do anything about it. Nothing, nada, zilch. You're beating a very dead horse here."
My reponse going forward.
Jim the NCAA can not do anything about the CBA but they can enact things to address how the CBA affects them.
One thing the NCAA did which you could argue combats early entry is the Lowes Senior class award. If you come back to school for your senior year you can win this award. I am almost 100% sure this does not influence whether a junior decides to come back to school for his senior year, but at least it is something that the NCAA tried.
The other way to look at this is with perhaps another bad analogy, but I will attempt the analogy anyway. When I was growing up the drinking age in New Jersey was 18. However, some municpalities did not want drunk 18 years old walking around their town at night, so the municipalities set curfews, limited the hours that bars could be open and in some extreme cases banded all alcohol. These municipalities did not change the drinking age but set rules to cover the consequences of the drinking age law they did not like.
The NCAA could most certainly think of some rules to do the same. My first suggestion was an example of a penalty approach. Here is a reward approach. The NCAA could take the $100K that would be used for a scholarship and put it in a trust fund/annuity. If you get your degree in 6 years (or something reasonable) the money is all yours if not the NCAA keeps it. The flaw with this is that the NCAA is greedy.
However, in a few years time the NCAA may be hosting a Final Four and be giving a trophy to a team of NBA caliber freshman who won't be back for their sophmore years. If this picture is ok with the NCAA then there is no issue.
Let me pose this another way
If we assume that student-athletes that leave after one year is a bad thing for college basketball and we know that the NBA will not change their rule,
What could be done by the NCAA or member institutions to keep student-athletes in school for more than one year?
I know you guys and gals are pretty smart so instead of finding all the flaws with various plans what would you do?