Originally Posted by
Newton_14
A few things to consider here. First, except for the dumb dead ball foul, Mason played a heck of a game. This despite only getting 3 shot attempts. He defended really well, had amazing passes and was all over the place making things happen. People will point to MSU missing "easy shots", but much of that was due to the pressure the 3 bigs were putting on the MSU bigs. Our bigs challenged shots, especially Mason and Kelly, and either blocked, altered, or caused MSU to rush numerous shotsl Give some credit to the defense.
I strongly agree with these points. Miles did not have a good game, but I think that Mason and Ryan, especially in the 2nd half for Ryan, had very good games. Mason is really showing some good things in the post offensively with his moves and passing. He is not Jared Sullinger yet, but his footwork and composure are greatly improved. Also agree that those interior "bunnies" that MSU missed were almost all strongly challenged by the interior D.
Originally Posted by
brumby041
What is the impetus for "going to the monitor"?
They went for Mason's (stupid) elbow and Nix's box out, neither of which I thought warranted a call. Yet they let the (obvious to me) knee to Thornton's head go??? That looked like it had to potential to really hurt Tyler.
Would love an explanation.
-Brumby
This really bothers me too. I understand the need to go to the monitor to make sure that you get things right in a big fracas situation. However, if MSU's Thornton hadn't whined about the little shove that he got from Mason I don't think the refs would have gone to the monitor. The Nix shove to Andre on the FT was even more ticky-tack. If we go the monitor you can find contact like these two examples on probably 50% of all plays. Overuse of the monitor really disrupts the flow of the game. The announcers hinted at Mason's "shove" being an issue because it was a dead ball. Nix's shove was after a made FT. Is this a dead ball situation? The Nix knee to Tyler's head was happening just as a foul was being called and I guess wasn't actually a dead ball. Is this the difference?
Is it the possibility of an elbow being thrown? I know they can go to the monitor for this. Mason's and Nix's shoves could have possibly been elbows so that would make sense but neither of them were actually elbows yet fouls were still called. I know that there are some former refs that post on here. Do any of you have any clarification?
My thoughts on the inability to finish games issue are 2-fold. One, the primary ballhandlers in these situations so far (Seth and Tyler) either haven't been on the court much in these situations in college (Tyler) or haven't been the primary ballhandler when on the court (Seth). All the players (Scheyer, Nolan, Kyle, Kyrie) that typically dominated the ball in end game situations the last 2 years are gone. Composure with the game on the line can't really be replicated in practice. Seth had three bad plays (an early shot that led to a breakout, a travel, and the horrendous 3/4 court alley-oop attempt to Mason) vs one good play (the drive to basket and nice finish) in the last 5 minutes. Hopefully, he will improve. I also really think that Quinn could be beneficial in these situations. Hopefully, early season games will allow him to get more PT and will allow Coach K to be more comfortable using him. That kind of segues to my second point, fatigue. Coach K actually referenced after both the Belmont and MSU games that the players might have been a little tired at the end. I know that winning the Belmont and MSU games was important for a young team's psyche, but I hope that Quinn, Gbinije and Alex get a little more playing time in future early season games to hopefully keep everyone a little fresher at the end.
Coach K on Kyle Singler - "What position does he play? ... He plays winner."
"Duke is never the underdog" - Quinn Cook