Originally Posted by
Olympic Fan
I have not seen this kid play, except on a couple of mix tapes, but based on what I've read or heard from people I respect, I think Andre Dawkins is a better comp for Tucker than Luke Maye (as one poster suggests). It's hard to compare rankings, since Dawkins was such a late re-classification that he never showed up in the 2009 class rankings, but he was likely just outside the top 25 in that class, somewhere in the 30s ... close to Tucker's No. 40 in ESPN (the final RSCI is not out yet).
Of course, we'll never know long-term until we find out what kind of work ethic the kid has and how strong he is mentally, but in physical terms, he's not a great athlete, but he's better than Maye. Yes, he's close to Maye in height, but he has a much better vertical and is quicker ... Maye is probably stronger.
The big difference is skills -- the strength of Tucker's game at the moment is his shooting ability. He needs to work on his handle and on his defensive game .,.. sound like anybody we know with the initials AD?
I hope that Tucker can play the same kind of role in 2016-17 that freshman Andre Dawkins played in 2010 -- as a spot-up shooter off the bench. Beyond that, I hope he does a better job of developing his game than Dawkins (who, to be fair, had to deal with some very serious off-court stuff).
I like the front page comparison with Knox, in that Knox is likely to be significantly better as a freshman, but as a 3-4 year player, Tucker is likely to contribute more over the course of his career than a OAD.
In a way, it's like Kenny Anderson vs. Bobby Hurley. Over his two years at Georgia Tech, Anderson had more individual success than Hurley at Duke. But Anderson left after two years and Hurley had two more great years. His four years were a greater contribution than Anderson's two. You could say the same thing about Joel Berry vs. Tyus Jones ... both were freshmen in 2015, when Tyus blew him away ... but Berry has stayed and has given the Cheats three (and soon to be four) years, including a national title and another Final Four. Tyus was the better player, but Berry has had the better college career.