Originally Posted by
CDu
So, we're in late-February, which means bubble watch time. As of now, I think it is safe to say that six ACC teams are comfortably in: UNC-CH, Louisville, FSU, Duke, UVa, and Notre Dame. From there, it gets interesting.
Virginia Tech (18-7, 7-6, RPI 33, Pomeroy 49): The Hokies have wins over Duke and UVa at home, but then have lost to State by a bunch in Raleigh. Still, I think that their general lack of bad losses combined with a relatively manageable back end of the schedule (@Louisville, but then home against Clemson, Miami, and Wake, and @BC) will get them in. It will be tricky after losing their leading rebounder for the season. But if they can get to 10-8 in conference, I think they will be in. That realistically means winning two of their three home games and beating BC.
Syracuse (16-11, 8-6 ACC, RPI 76, Pomeroy 48): The Cuse has fared pretty well so far in conference. Wins over FSU and UVa look great, and they avoided losses to Wake and Clemson in heart-stopping fashion. The RPI is not pretty at all, nor are the blowout losses to BC and St John's. Pomeroy is a bit more forgiving. The Cuse have two games against Ga Tech, a home game against us, and a road game against Louisville. They probably need both of those Tech games to feel good about their chances. If they end up 9-9 in conference and 17-14 overall, I think they miss the dance. And it is not inconceivable for them to lose out, which would certainly eliminate them.
Miami (17-8, 7-6, RPI 49, Pomeroy 35): The Canes are sort of strangely different from Cuse despite similar conference records. Miami has just one truly impressive win (blowing out UNC at home). What they have done is for the most part avoid bad losses. They haven't lost to a team outside the RPI top-80 (@Syracuse is their worst loss). Unfortunately, they also don't have many impressive wins. Just 2-7 against the RPI top-50 (5-8 against the RPI top-100) illustrates that what the Canes have mainly done is beat the teams they should beat. Their schedule gets tougher, as they close with Clemson, @UVa, Duke, @Va Tech, and @FSU. They could very conceivably lose any/all of those games. Beating Clemson is a borderline must, because I'd expect them to lose 3 of their last 4. And I don't think their resume would get them in at 9-9 in conference with just the 2 or 3 top-50 wins. They would certainly be sweating it out at 19-11 and 9-9 in conference.
Georgia Tech (15-11, 6-7, RPI 78, Pomeroy 78: The Jackets are a really bizarre case. Losses to Ohio and Penn State are not great. Nor is the sub-.500 record in conference. The RPI and Pomeroy marks both look unfavorable. And yet, they have wins over UNC, FSU, and Notre Dame. Those are REALLY impressive scalps. They finish the year with a pair against Syracuse (so one of the Cuse and Ga Tech are definitely out of at-large consideration), a road game against Notre Dame (they could REALLY boost their case with a win in South Bend), and must-win games against State and Pitt. My feeling is that they will lose 3 of 5 and miss out. But if they win out? I think they stamp their ticket. Anything less than 4-1 down the stretch probably keeps them out.
Clemson (14-11, 4-9, RPI 53, Pomeroy 36): Man, I feel bad for Brad Brownell and Clemson. They are a good team. But they have lost EIGHT games by 6 points or less, including four games by 3 points or less. If they even win two of those four super close games I'd actually put their case as about the same as Miami. But they just can't seem to finish. The bright side? If Clemson runs the table (@Miami, @Va Tech, and home versus FSU, State, and BC), they finish 19-11 and 9-9 in conference with wins over South Carolina and FSU, not to mention finishing on a 6-game win streak. And both their RPI (likely in the top-40) and Pomeroy (likely top-30) would look very nice.
Wake Forest (15-11, 6-8, RPI 38, Pomeroy 34): Wake has had some tough luck too. They are in a slightly better place than Clemson, but I think they probably need to win 3 of 4 to feel good. They don't have any great wins. They have just 4 wins against the current RPI top-100 (against a boatload of losses). Because of that, I don't think simply finishing .500 or better in conference is enough. They need to get some nice wins. Road game against Duke would help (hopefully they lose though). So would a home game against Louisville. Aside from that, they have a home game against Pitt and what is likely an elimination game for them at Va Tech.
If I had to guess, I'd say that Va Tech and Syracuse get in, and one or two of the others will be on the bubble. Several of these teams play each other (Va Tech, for instance, could single-handedly bury the hopes of Wake and Clemson and put Miami in danger as well).