Well, I suppose that I am supposed to chime in now. I think it is very likely that Miller is transferring and have thought so since around early November/the Michigan State game. Barrett's ability to throw, work through his progressions and make quick decisions was better, at that point, that Miller's. And Barrett is a red shirt fresh who hadn't played in 18 months due to a knee injury. Miller just isn't as good as Barrett in the passing game.
It seems likely to me, that the OSU coaching staff, and specifically Meyer has been honest with Miller and told him that the job isn't automatically his next year. Plus, can you imagine if Jones plays remotely well in the playoff? Then you've got a three way battle going into the spring, and one guy who is staring down the barell of his last season. A transfer is probably in the works.
I think Adam's posting is probably true...Miller probably has reached out to or expressed interest in duke, but more specifically in Cutty, as he wants to play QB in the NFL. However, much like his predecessor, Pryor, the knock has been his throwing ability. Wouldn't it make sense to work under Cutty for spring ball and the following season to try to upgrade the draft stock? Miller could end up looking like a Teddy Bridgewater or a more mature Johnny Manziel. That wouldn't be so bad.
Also, Miller probably figures that he could still go the Dennard Robinson route and end up as a back in the NFL given his absurd running ability and elusiveness. I was at the OSU-Penn State game a few years ago and saw this in person
(go to about the 2:09 mark) And I still am not sure it actually happened. So I think Miller to Duke
could make sense.
That said, I think Duke is probably a long shot. Miller isn't going to Michigan. He isn't going to do Meyer like that and he isn't Justin Boren who was pissed when Carr was forced out at Michigan, had been an OSU recruit and whose brother, Zach, was committed to OSU. What makes more sense to me is either Oregon for a year, or Texas. Texas is in a heap of trouble at QB and would probably guarantee Miller the starting job. Oregon would just plug him in and run their offense without missing a beat. So, what does Duke do? Add some read option and teach the kid to throw? Maybe. I sure hope so, but until Cutty is telling me that it is happening, I will still think it's a long shot.
And in all fairness, I love Braxton Miller. That kid was thrown into a poop storm after Tresell/Pryor/tattoo-gate and did nothing but put his behind on the line for OSU. He has been injured several times, but most have been related to big time hits that go along with running the read option in a fast paced college system, and, for better or worse, the kid doesn't shy away from contact.
So there's my two cents...for what it's worth. I hope to hell that he does end up at Duke next year. I think his dynamic nature and leadership abilities would make Duke a favorite in the Coastal and give us a chance to win the ACC.