Well, maybe, although according to ESPN he only had 14 points. I think the point is that 14 (or even 16) quiet points against a low-major isn't really the stuff first-team All Americans are made of. In that sense he may be overrated, because it will be surprising (at least to me) if he's a first-team AA by the end of the year.
Having said that, I agree with you that anyone who's calling him a "bust" at this point is being a little bit silly.