I had a feeling I'd hear from you after my comment.
I know you've seen Josh play, but I believe most of your opinion of Josh is from his time prior to Montrose.
From what I've been told by people who have watched him this year, he is a much improved player. IMO, he will play a very big role if Kyle leaves
I also disagree with your premise of Ryan as a "perimeter guy.". Ryan was recruited to a big with perimeter skills. Josh will be given more freedom to roam outside than Ryan was or will be, especially in a more wide open 4 out, 1 in system next year but I'd hardly call him a perimeter guy.
We have all Summer to differ on this, and neither of us will be proven right or wrong until probably the end of next season.