Yeah, it was pretty wacky -- and as a lifelong Giant fan, I suspect I would have rather annoyed if he had made it. Then again, I LOVED the idea of it, and that it is still in the rules of the NFL.
I think that most things out-of-the-ordinary (for most sports) brings excitement, as well as a ....I didn't know that. Actually I thought it was a great call -- and although I OF COURSE didn't want him to make the kick -- I wish it had been closer.