Not trying to re-open the debate, but I thought this article pretty much covers the points (and counter points) that we hashed through here, with some additional stats:
http://www.charlotteobserver.com/spo...ry/470999.html

One interesting point - at the end it covers what options for QB the Panthers realistically have. They are summarized as:
Roster:
Matt Moore, Brett Basanez, Josh McCown (broke his leg in preseason)
Free Agents:
  • Warner, Collins, Garcia, all of which are old or older than Delhomme

  • Matt Cassell, althought the Patriots may Franchise him.

  • Others are Rex Grossman, Jon Kitna, Kyle Boller, Charlie Batch, J.P. Losman, Patrick Ramsey, J.T. O'Sullivan and Byron Leftwich.

Draft:
Josh Freeman of Kansas State or Ball State's Nate Davis potentially.