hoopscoop.com ranks college coaches
I saw this on http://www.cbssports.com/collegebask.../post/18115828[ (I don't get why they don't put links in) about a website called www.hoopscooponline.com that ranks college coaches, some very interesting opinions, and criteria. I kind of wonder about the rankings though. Is Calhoun the 2nd best coach in the country? Should Tony Bennett (UVA) rank ahead of M. Gottfried (NC State)? The up and coming coaches and asst. coach rankings are also somewhat surprising.
http://www.hoopscooponline.com/membe...kings-2012.asp
Just putting this up for conversation, and to see what people think about the Duke coach rankings. I know this means very little in the grand scheme of things.
Reall Good Caoches or Really Good Results?
I didn't see an approach discussed that explained the rankings. I think most of us could put together a spreadsheet and develop a scheme where coaches get so many points for wins, for Final Fours and for National Championships, so it is instructive to look at deviations from that norm.
Lower than expected --
- Tom Izzo at no. 8 despite 6 FFs and 1 NC. I would put Izzo at #2 -- he brings it year-in and year-out and he passes the character test with flying colors.
- Billy Donovan at no. 10 despite 3 and 2. Donovan at no. 10 is probably fair, in that his major accomplishments were with one group of players, although he did have a FF run in 2000 (which we painfully remember).
- Brad Stevens at no. 13 despite two FFs. Brad Stevens should probably be ranked higher, although the overall ranking suggests a lot of weight given to longevity. It raises an interesting question: do major accomplishments at a school in a lesser conference deserve higher weight?
- Ben Howland at no. 25 despite three FFs. Well, let's agree that, given the problems at UCLA, we should be surprised that Howland is anywhere in the Top 50.
Higher than expected:
- John Calipari at #3 despite only one FF (not the three in the table) and no NCs. No question he is the hot coach with the right platform and the right marketing message for the one-and-done era, but I wouldn't put him in the top ten because of the cheating that occurred on his watch.
- Bill Self at no. 6 ahead of the more credentialed Boeheim, Izzo and Donovan. This morning it looks like a good ranking.
- Bob Huggins at no. 9 without a NC and just two FF appearances. I think there is too much debris in his wake to justify a higher than merited ranking.
- Bo Ryan at no. 11 without a FF appearance. OK, if you say that positions 11 through 20 are all pretty much the same.
- Tubby Smith at no. 14? Not on my list.
- Sean Miller, Scott Drew and Mike Brey in the top 20 without ever reaching a FF? I'm OK with all three, I think.
My other objection is Jim Calhoun at #2. Calhoun gets credit for building a program from scratch and for turning four FF appearances into three NCs. But the down years are really down and the problems around the program are way too high to give him this ranking.
My top five would be --
Krzyzewski
Izzo
R. Williams
Pitino
Self
sagegrouse