Didn't that happen in 2010 with the Cardinals and Mets? I remember the game in late April, on a Saturday when I was planning on going out, but the game took forever, 19 innings. (No, checking Baseball-reference.com, there were two position players who finished for the Cards, Felipe Lopez and Joe Mather, but not one on each side.)
I remember Wade Boggs pitching for the Yankees once. The batters said he had a great knuckleball. He retired as a player at age 41. Could have lasted another 10 years as a pitcher!